Differences between revisions 52 and 74 (spanning 22 versions) Back to page
Revision 52 as of 5:24PM, Nov 12, 2013
Size: 4248
Editor: Sam
Comment:
Revision 74 as of 6:11PM, Dec 16, 2013
Size: 5280
Editor: Sam
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
 * The exam score was '''235 &pm; 90 out of 350''' (400, if incl. extra credit). I think this score distribution is quite decent. The exra credit from the forum discussion has not been applied yet. Actually, any one is welcome to contribute more to the discussion and get credits on the pre-midterm problems.&mdash;~-''<<DateTime(2013-11-12T16:22:50-0800)>>''-~  * '''Final exam'''
Line 5: Line 5:
    * If you can describe a new solution that is much simpler, then that will have value to all students.&mdash;we can remember simple things the best.
    * Even if this simplifying process depends on an existing solution, it is OK, as long as you assimilate the existing solution and present a clearly new view.
    * There are problems (8b and 10) that have not been answered.
     * I hope you showed your best in the final exam. Here is <<la("E02.pdf", "the final exam")>> ~-(<<la(E02-w-Sols.pdf, "with solutions")>>)-~.
Line 9: Line 7:
 * I hope you did well on the exam. Here is the exam: ~-<<la("E01.pdf", "problems only")>>, <<la("E01-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>.-~&mdash;~-''<<DateTime(2013-11-05T16:37:42-0800)>>''-~  <<clr>>
 <<lia("E02-histogram.png")>>
 <<clr>>
Line 11: Line 11:
 * We have our midterm coming up next Tuesday (Nov 5). This will be the only in-class exam, as the final exam will be a take-home exam. Here are some resources.  * '''Midterm exam'''
Line 13: Line 13:
 * <<la("Review for Midterm.pdf", "Summary of the review session (Nov 2)")>>.
   * In addition to what I summarized here, we also discussed problem 6 of the practice midterm briefly. Here is what I said. The setup here boils down to the initial state at $t = 0$, which evolves in time, as governed by the Hamiltonian. The time evolution for this Hamiltonian (constant B field coupling to spin) corresponds to the rotation of the spin around the direction of the magnetic field. Initially, the spin is up along the $z$ direction. So, for part (a), there won't be any change to the state (except for a phase accumulation). For part (b), the state will rotate in the $yz$ plane with the Larmor precession frequency. You must do the math to illustrate these points, using the same math that we used in early homework problems, but expect (and confirm) these behaviors.
     * The exam score was '''235 &pm; 90 out of 350''' (400, if incl. extra credit). I think this score distribution is quite decent. The exra credit from the forum discussion has not been applied yet. Actually, any one is welcome to contribute more to the discussion and get credits on the pre-midterm problems.&mdash;~-''<<DateTime(2013-11-12T16:22:50-0800)>>''-~
Line 16: Line 15:
 * <<la("Last-midterm.pdf", "Last year's midterm exam")>>: There were a bit too many problems. I think this year's exam should be about two problems less.         * If you can describe a new solution that is much simpler, then that will have value to all students&mdash;we can remember simple things the best.
        * Even if this simplifying process depends on an existing solution, it is OK, as long as you assimilate the existing solution and present a clearly new view.
        * There are problems (8b and 10) that have not been answered.
Line 18: Line 19:
 * <<la("Review-last-midterm.pdf", "The review summary of the last year's review for the midterm")>>.      * I hope you did well on the exam. Here is the exam: <<la("E01.pdf", "problems only")>>, ~-<<la("E01-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>.-~&mdash;~-''<<DateTime(2013-11-05T16:37:42-0800)>>''-~
Line 20: Line 21:
== Quiz ==      * We have our midterm coming up next Tuesday (Nov 5). This will be the only in-class exam, as the final exam will be a take-home exam. Here are some resources.
Line 22: Line 23:
 * '''Quiz 3''', ~-Oct 29-~: <<la("Q03-Symmetry+.pdf", "Virial theorem, Symmetry")>> ~-(<<la("Q03-Symmetry+-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~      * <<la("Review for Midterm.pdf", "Summary of the review session (Nov 2)")>>.
       * In addition to what I summarized here, we also discussed problem 6 of the practice midterm briefly. Here is what I said. The setup here boils down to the initial state at $t = 0$, which evolves in time, as governed by the Hamiltonian. The time evolution for this Hamiltonian (constant B field coupling to spin) corresponds to the rotation of the spin around the direction of the magnetic field. Initially, the spin is up along the $z$ direction. So, for part (a), there won't be any change to the state (except for a phase accumulation). For part (b), the state will rotate in the $yz$ plane with the Larmor precession frequency. You must do the math to illustrate these points, using the same math that we used in early homework problems, but expect (and confirm) these behaviors.
Line 24: Line 26:
 * '''Quiz 2''', ~-Oct 22-~: <<la("Q02-Perturbation.pdf", "Perturbation")>> ~-(<<la("Q02-Perturbation-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~      * <<la("Last-midterm.pdf", "Last year's midterm exam")>>: There were a bit too many problems. I think this year's exam should be about two problems less.
Line 26: Line 28:
 * '''Quiz 1''', ~-Oct 15-~: <<la("Q01-Formalism.pdf", "Formalism")>> ~-(<<la("Q01-Formalism-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~      * <<la("Review-last-midterm.pdf", "The review summary of the last year's review for the midterm")>>.
Line 30: Line 32:
 * '''Homework 6''', ~-due Nov 19-~: <<la("H06-Perturbation-TD.pdf", "Time-dependent perturbation")>>  * '''Homework 8''', ~-not due, but must do-~: <<la(H08-Scattering-and-Berry-phase.pdf, "Scattering and Berry phase")>>
Line 32: Line 34:
 * '''Homework 5''', ~-due Nov 12-~: <<la("H05-VP-WKB.pdf", "Variational principle, WKB, Bohr-Sommerfeld")>>  * '''Homework 7''', ~-due Dec 4-~: <<la("H07-Electron-and-photon.pdf", "Interaction of light and matter")>> ~-(<<la(H07-Electron-and-photon-w-Sols.pdf, "with solutions")>>)-~

 * '''Homework 6''', ~-due Nov <<color(21)>>-~: <<la("H06-Perturbation-TD.pdf", "Time-dependent perturbation")>> ~-(<<la(H06-Perturbation-TD-w-Sols.pdf, "with solutions")>>)-~

 {{{#!wiki comment
  * <<color("Correction:")>> Sign mistake in solution (page 8) and subsequent corrections (red).&mdash;~-''<<DateTime(2013-11-25T16:17:20-0800)>>''-~
 }}}

 * '''Homework 5''', ~-due Nov 12-~: <<la("H05-VP-WKB.pdf", "Variational principle, WKB, Bohr-Sommerfeld")>> ~-(<<la(H05-VP-WKB-w-Sols.pdf, "with solutions")>>)-~
Line 51: Line 61:

== Quiz ==

 * '''Quiz 4''', ~-Nov 26-~: <<la(Q04-VP-WKB.pdf, "Bohr-Sommerfeld rule")>> ~-(<<la(Q04-VP-WKB-w-Sols.pdf, "with solutions")>>)-~

 * '''Quiz 3''', ~-Oct 29-~: <<la("Q03-Symmetry+.pdf", "Virial theorem, Symmetry")>> ~-(<<la("Q03-Symmetry+-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~

 * '''Quiz 2''', ~-Oct 22-~: <<la("Q02-Perturbation.pdf", "Perturbation")>> ~-(<<la("Q02-Perturbation-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~

 * '''Quiz 1''', ~-Oct 15-~: <<la("Q01-Formalism.pdf", "Formalism")>> ~-(<<la("Q01-Formalism-w-Sols.pdf", "with solutions")>>)-~

Exam

  • Final exam

    Inlined image: E02-histogram.png
  • Midterm exam

    • The exam score was 235 ± 90 out of 350 (400, if incl. extra credit). I think this score distribution is quite decent. The exra credit from the forum discussion has not been applied yet. Actually, any one is welcome to contribute more to the discussion and get credits on the pre-midterm problems.—5:22PM, Nov 12, 2013

      • If you can describe a new solution that is much simpler, then that will have value to all students—we can remember simple things the best.

      • Even if this simplifying process depends on an existing solution, it is OK, as long as you assimilate the existing solution and present a clearly new view.
      • There are problems (8b and 10) that have not been answered.
    • I hope you did well on the exam. Here is the exam: problems only, with solutions.5:37PM, Nov 05, 2013

    • We have our midterm coming up next Tuesday (Nov 5). This will be the only in-class exam, as the final exam will be a take-home exam. Here are some resources.
    • Summary of the review session (Nov 2).

      • In addition to what I summarized here, we also discussed problem 6 of the practice midterm briefly. Here is what I said. The setup here boils down to the initial state at $t = 0$, which evolves in time, as governed by the Hamiltonian. The time evolution for this Hamiltonian (constant B field coupling to spin) corresponds to the rotation of the spin around the direction of the magnetic field. Initially, the spin is up along the $z$ direction. So, for part (a), there won't be any change to the state (except for a phase accumulation). For part (b), the state will rotate in the $yz$ plane with the Larmor precession frequency. You must do the math to illustrate these points, using the same math that we used in early homework problems, but expect (and confirm) these behaviors.

    • Last year’s midterm exam: There were a bit too many problems. I think this year's exam should be about two problems less.

    • The review summary of the last year’s review for the midterm.

Homework

Quiz